top of page
SSS_Large.jpg

Preparing Without Frightening: How to Engage Students in Age-Appropriate School Safety Training

Sep 23
12 min read

School safety training presents educators with a difficult balance. We want students to know what to do during an emergency. We want them to recognize important safety information. We want them to listen to adults, make appropriate decisions, report concerns, and understand the emergency procedures used by their school.

But we do not want to create unnecessary fear in the process. That balance has become increasingly important as emergency preparedness has become a routine part of the school experience.

According to the National Center for Education Statistics, during the 2021--22 school year, 96% of public schools conducted lockdown drills with students, 93% conducted shelter-in-place drills, and 93% conducted evacuation drills. Students are clearly participating in school safety activities. The more important question for school and district leaders is:

Are we teaching school safety in a way that actually helps students become more prepared?

That requires more than determining how many drills students should complete. It requires thinking carefully about what students need to know, how we communicate it, how instruction changes by developmental level, and how students can become participants in preparedness without carrying responsibilities that belong to adults.

We Already Teach Young Children How to Respond to Emergencies

There is an important point that sometimes gets lost in conversations about age-appropriate school safety training:

Teaching young children what to do during an emergency is not a new concept.

Consider fire safety. Generations of children have learned:

Stop. Drop. Roll.

We teach children that simple action because there is a possibility---however unlikely---that their clothing could catch fire. But good fire-safety education does not require showing a kindergarten student graphic images of burn injuries. We teach the action, not the horror of the event. The same thing happens with fire drills.

Young students learn that when the alarm sounds, they stop what they are doing, follow their teacher, leave the building, go to an assigned location, and remain with their class. We can even look beyond schools. Children who travel on airplanes hear safety instructions before every flight. Seat belt. Oxygen mask. Emergency exits. Flotation devices. Brace positions.

Those instructions address potentially catastrophic events, yet they are presented calmly, routinely, and without attempting to frighten passengers into compliance. There is a lesson here for school safety.

Preparedness does not require fear.

We can acknowledge that emergencies occur while concentrating instruction on the simple actions people can take to stay safe. That should be one of our foundational principles when teaching students about school emergencies.

Start With What Students Actually Need to Know

One of the easiest mistakes in school safety training is giving students information because adults believe the information is important. A better starting point is:

What does the student actually need to know or be able to do?

During most emergencies, students do not need a detailed understanding of the threat. They need to understand the action. Where should I go? What should I do? Who should I listen to? What happens if I am not with my teacher? How do I report something that concerns me? What should I do if the normal procedure cannot be followed? That distinction matters.

We can prepare students for emergencies without providing graphic descriptions of violence or unnecessarily detailed explanations of worst-case scenarios. The U.S. Department of Education recommends that school emergency preparedness include training, exercises, and age-appropriate drills reflecting the specific needs of the school. The goal should be competence---not fear.

Think again about Stop, Drop, and Roll. We do not begin by teaching children everything that adults know about structure fires, burn injuries, or fire behavior. We identify a potentially life-saving action, explain it in understandable language, demonstrate it, and give children an opportunity to practice. School emergency preparedness can follow the same instructional logic:

Explain → Demonstrate → Practice → Reinforce

Age-Appropriate Does Not Mean Less Prepared

Sometimes "age appropriate" is interpreted as simply providing younger students with less information. I think there is a better way to look at it.

The objective can remain consistent while the way we teach it changes.

Consider evacuation. A kindergarten student and a high school senior both need to understand how to evacuate safely. But we should not teach them the same way. For younger students, instruction might emphasize:

  • Listening to the teacher.

  • Staying with the group.

  • Moving calmly to the designated location.

  • Knowing that adults and helpers are there to keep them safe.

  • Practicing the action in a familiar and reassuring way.

Older students can handle greater context and more complex questions:

  • What if you are in the restroom when an evacuation occurs?

  • What if your normal route is blocked?

  • What if you are outside the building?

  • Why is student accountability important?

  • Why shouldn't you leave the evacuation area without telling someone?

The safety objective is the same. The instructional approach is different. That is what developmentally appropriate safety education should look like.

For Younger Students: Familiarity, Simplicity and Reassurance

For our youngest students, school safety instruction should look much more like good elementary instruction than emergency-response training. Use simple language. Use repetition. Use familiar adults. Use stories. Use visual cues. Practice expected behaviors. Keep explanations concrete.

This is an area where The "I Love U Guys" Foundation has taken an especially thoughtful approach with its PreK--2+ Standard Response Protocol resources.

The *Learn From the Helpers: 5 Actions That Keep Us Safe* materials introduce emergency actions through familiar helpers, conversations, illustrations, stories, lesson plans, social stories, posters, and classroom activities. The approach makes sense because it resembles other safety education already familiar to young children.

We don't need to explain everything that could cause a school to evacuate before teaching a child how to evacuate. We don't need to describe a destructive tornado before teaching a child where to shelter.

And we don't need to provide graphic descriptions of violence before teaching a child that sometimes their teacher may need to secure the classroom and have everyone remain quiet.

Teach the protective action at the developmental level of the child.

For younger students, the message might simply be:

"There are different things we do at school to help keep everyone safe. Your teachers will help you know what to do."

That creates preparedness without making fear the instructional strategy.

For Older Students: Add Context and Decision-Making

As students get older, school safety education can become more sophisticated. Middle and high school students are capable of understanding more about why emergency procedures exist and how circumstances may affect their actions. That does not mean every safety lesson needs to become more frightening. It means the discussion can become more practical.

Instead of only teaching a high school student what Lockdown means, ask:

What would you do if a Lockdown were announced while you were in the restroom?

What if you were in the cafeteria? Outside? Between classes? At athletic practice? What if you could not safely get back into the building? Those are very different questions from simply asking students to memorize a protocol. We can also help older students understand the reasons behind certain expectations.

Why shouldn't students immediately call parents during some emergencies? Why is accountability important during an evacuation? Why might students be moved to another location for reunification? Why shouldn't someone open a secured exterior door simply because another student is knocking? Why is it important to report concerning behavior?

Older students can understand the why behind the procedure. And understanding why can make the action more meaningful.

Older Students Can Be More Than Participants in Drills

There is another opportunity that I think schools sometimes overlook. As students mature, their role in preparedness can evolve beyond simply receiving training and participating in drills. Middle and particularly high school students can become an important source of information about how safety actually functions on their campus.

That does not mean assigning students responsibility for securing the school, confronting dangerous people, investigating threats, or performing responsibilities that belong to trained adults. It means recognizing something fairly obvious:

Students experience our campuses differently than adults do.

They know where students gather before school. They know which hallways become congested between classes. They know where students go during lunch. They know whether announcements can be heard in the locker room. They know which exterior areas students routinely use. They know whether their peers understand the terminology used during drills.

And they often know which safety messages students take seriously---and which ones they tune out. Federal REMS guidance identifies students as an important, and sometimes overlooked, stakeholder in emergency preparedness and describes opportunities for age-appropriate student participation in preparedness activities. Schools can use that perspective.

Create Appropriate Opportunities for Student Voice

For older students, consider establishing a student safety advisory group or incorporating safety into an existing student leadership organization. Periodically ask students to provide feedback on preparedness issues. For example:

Can you hear emergency announcements everywhere you spend time?

Which emergency procedures are confusing to students?

Do students know how to report a safety concern?

Do students understand what happens during reunification?

Where are students most likely to be during arrival, dismissal, lunch, and passing periods?

What questions do students have after drills?

Students might also participate appropriately in:

  • Post-drill feedback.

  • Campus safety surveys.

  • Emergency communication reviews.

  • Preparedness awareness campaigns.

  • Development of student-facing safety materials.

  • Discussions about anonymous reporting and help-seeking.

  • Age-appropriate tabletop exercises.

  • Student government or advisory discussions about campus safety.

  • Reviewing whether emergency messages are understandable from a student's perspective.

Imagine asking a group of high school students to review the school's student-facing emergency information. Adults may think the information is perfectly clear. Students may immediately identify terminology their peers do not understand. That is useful data.

Students Can Help Us See the Campus Differently

There is another simple activity school leaders can conduct with older students. Give them a campus map. Ask them to identify where students actually are at different times of the day. Before school. Passing periods. Lunch. Dismissal. Athletic practice. Extracurricular activities. Then ask:

If an emergency occurred during this time, what questions would students have?

The purpose is not to ask students to write the Emergency Operations Plan. The adults remain responsible for planning, decision-making, supervision, and response. Instead, the exercise allows students to help adults identify assumptions. This is the same reason we include people from different departments when evaluating an emergency plan.

Transportation sees something administrators may not. Facilities sees something teachers may not. School nurses see something safety personnel may not. And students see things adults may not.

Student voice can be another source of information for improving the system.

Teach Reporting as a Safety Skill

One of the most important safety behaviors we can teach students has nothing to do with a drill. It is how to ask for help. Students should understand: What kinds of concerns should be reported? Who can I tell? What if the first adult does not seem to understand my concern? Is there an anonymous reporting option? What happens after I report something?

Why is reporting different from trying to get someone in trouble? This deserves intentional instruction. Simply installing an anonymous reporting application or placing a reporting link on the district website does not mean students know when or how to use it. Schools should normalize help-seeking and reporting as part of the broader safety culture.

The message should be straightforward:

If something makes you concerned about your safety or someone else's safety, tell a trusted adult.

For older students, this discussion can become more nuanced. What if the concern appears on social media? What if a friend asks you not to tell? What if you aren't sure whether something is serious? What if someone says they were "just joking"? Those are realistic situations students encounter.

Giving them permission to report uncertainty may be just as important as teaching them to report an obvious threat.

Explain Before You Drill

Another practical recommendation is remarkably simple:

Teach the procedure before asking students to practice it.

A drill should not be the first time a student hears the terminology or learns what is expected. Instruction should come first. Students should know: What action are we practicing? What does it mean? What will happen? What are students expected to do?

How will we know when the exercise is over? Again, think about fire safety. We teach children what the alarm means and what they are expected to do. Then we practice. Or consider an airplane safety briefing. Passengers receive the instructions before there is an emergency. That is the point of preparedness. The emergency is not the teaching environment.

We teach beforehand so the expected action is more familiar when it is needed.

Training teaches. Drills practice.

We should not expect the drill to do both jobs.

Don't Confuse Realism With Effectiveness

There is sometimes an assumption in emergency training that making an exercise feel more realistic automatically makes it better. That is not necessarily true---particularly with children. Schools should be extremely cautious about unnecessary simulation that may increase fear without improving the capability being tested. Ask:

What exactly are we trying to accomplish?

If the objective is to determine whether students understand how to secure a classroom, we can evaluate that without simulated gunfire. If the objective is evacuation and accountability, we can evaluate those capabilities without creating panic. If the objective is communication, test the communication system. Consider the airplane analogy again.

Flight attendants do not dim the cabin lights, fill the aircraft with simulated smoke, and create panic every time they teach passengers how to use an oxygen mask. They explain the action. They demonstrate it. Passengers know where the exits are. The safety equipment is available. The crew trains at a much higher level separately.

The level of training matches the role of the participant.

That principle translates remarkably well to schools. Students need training appropriate to the role we expect them to perform. Staff need more. Administrators and emergency response personnel may need substantially more. Realism should serve the objective.

The objective should never become realism itself.

Give Students Permission to Ask Questions

After instruction or a drill, ask students what they noticed. Not simply:

"Was everyone quiet?"

Ask:

What was confusing?

Was there anywhere you couldn't hear the announcement?

Did you know what you were supposed to do?

What questions do you still have?

Was there anything about the procedure that didn't make sense?

For younger students, that conversation may be brief and led by the classroom teacher. For older students, feedback can become more structured. A short anonymous survey after a drill might reveal that: Students in one hallway could not hear the announcement. Students at lunch were unsure where to go. Several students did not understand a particular term.

Students outside did not receive the notification at the same time as those inside. That turns student participation into information the district can use to improve preparedness.

Remember Students With Different Needs

Age is not the only factor leaders should consider. Students may have physical disabilities, sensory needs, communication differences, intellectual or developmental disabilities, English-language needs, or previous experiences that affect how they respond to emergency training. The right question is not simply:

"What should a sixth grader know?"

It is:

"What does this student need in order to understand and successfully perform the expected safety action?"

That may require: Visual supports. Social stories. Additional practice. Modified communication. Individualized assistance. Alternative evacuation procedures. Or additional preparation before a drill. Equitable preparedness means making sure our safety procedures are usable by the students we actually serve.

Families Should Understand What Students Are Being Taught

Parents and caregivers are also part of this conversation. Schools should explain: What emergency protocols are used. What students are being taught. How drills are conducted. How instruction is adjusted for younger students. What families should expect during an actual emergency. And, importantly, what parents should do. The goal should be consistency.

If the school tells students one thing while families unintentionally reinforce something completely different, confusion can increase during an emergency.

The Standard Response Protocol resources from The "I Love U Guys" Foundation include materials designed to help schools communicate protocols with students, staff, and families. Preparedness works better when those groups share a common understanding.

A Simple Framework for School Leaders

If I were evaluating a district's approach to student safety education and engagement, I would start with seven questions: 1. What do students actually need to know and do? Focus instruction on the actions and information students need to perform safely.

2. Is the instruction developmentally appropriate? The objective may remain consistent, but the instructional strategy should change by age and student need. 3. Are we teaching before we test? Students should understand the procedure before participating in a drill.

4. Are we creating competence without unnecessary fear? Every element of training should contribute to a legitimate learning objective. 5. Are older students given appropriate opportunities to contribute? Use student observations, feedback, leadership, and perspectives to strengthen the safety program without shifting adult responsibilities onto students.

6. Do students know how and when to report concerns? Treat help-seeking and reporting as skills that need to be intentionally taught. 7. Are we learning from students' experiences? Use student feedback, drill observations, surveys, and other evidence to improve the next training and the larger safety program.

That gives school and district leaders a much better framework than simply asking:

"How many student drills are required this year?"

Prepared Students, Not Scared Students

At School Safety Solutions, we believe preparedness should ultimately build confidence and capability. That is especially important when the people we are preparing are children. We already know how to do this.

We teach children to wear seat belts without showing them graphic images of automobile crashes. We teach Stop, Drop, and Roll without frightening them with descriptions of severe burns. We practice fire evacuation without setting fires in hallways. Airlines teach passengers how to use oxygen masks and locate emergency exits without attempting to recreate an aviation disaster.

In each case, the principle is similar:

Teach a simple protective action. Explain why it matters at an appropriate level. Practice it calmly. Reinforce it periodically.

School emergency preparedness should be approached with the same discipline. For younger students, that may mean stories, helpers, visual cues, repetition, reassurance, and simple actions.

For older students, it can include discussion, decision-making, reporting, situational questions, feedback, leadership, and meaningful participation in the school's broader preparedness efforts. For students with additional needs, it means making sure instruction and emergency procedures are accessible and meaningful.

And for every student, it means creating opportunities to learn and ask questions without making fear the teaching strategy. School safety training should not simply produce students who have participated in drills.

It should produce students who understand what to do, why it matters, and---when developmentally appropriate---how they can contribute to a safer school community. That gives school and district leaders a much better question to ask:

Are we simply exposing students to school safety procedures---or are we actually teaching and engaging them in ways that make our schools more prepared?

Want help building an age-appropriate student safety education program? Explore our school safety services or reach out to talk through next steps.

School Safety Solutions helps K-12 leaders strengthen prevention, protection, and preparedness through practical assessment, training, tabletop exercises, Standard Response Protocol implementation, behavioral threat assessment support, and reunification planning. If your district wants a calm, working review of its active shooter protocol and broader emergency readiness, visit School Safety Solutions or call 512-387-6729 to talk through next steps.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page