top of page
SSS_Large.jpg

The People We Forget to Plan For: Substitutes, Visitors, Contractors, and Volunteers During School Emergencies

Oct 17
9 min read

Walk into almost any school on a typical Tuesday morning and not everyone inside the building will be a regular employee. There may be substitute teachers covering classrooms, parents volunteering in the library, contractors repairing an HVAC system, a delivery driver at the loading dock, a university student completing classroom observations, a vendor working on technology, a guest speaker meeting with students, or a construction crew working in one wing of the building.

Most schools have procedures for determining whether these individuals are allowed to enter the building. But there is another question we don't ask nearly as often: once we let them inside, have we prepared them for what to do if something goes wrong? That distinction matters. Visitor management and emergency preparedness are related, but they are not the same thing. A visitor management system may tell us who is in the building. It does not necessarily mean the person knows what to do while they are there. And when an emergency occurs, that gap can become significant.

Our Emergency Plans Are Usually Built Around People Who Know the System

Think about how most school emergency preparedness programs operate. Employees receive training. Teachers participate in drills. Administrators attend tabletop exercises. Staff receive emails explaining updated procedures. Campus leaders learn their roles. Students practice protective actions throughout the year. Over time, regular employees develop something extremely valuable: familiarity. They know what an announcement means, where evacuation routes lead, and who normally makes decisions.

Now consider the substitute teacher who arrived at 7:35 that morning, the HVAC technician working above the ceiling in a mechanical room, or the parent volunteer helping in the cafeteria. They may be physically inside the same emergency while possessing only a fraction of that institutional knowledge. That creates a preparedness gap.

Start With a Different Question

Schools often ask: did this person check in? That is an important security question. But preparedness requires a second one: what does this person need to know before we send them into our building? The answer doesn't need to be a 45-minute emergency preparedness class. In fact, trying to give every visitor the same training as an employee would be unrealistic.

The better goal is to identify the minimum critical information someone needs based on why they are on campus, where they will be, and what responsibilities they may have during an emergency. That means schools should stop treating every nonemployee as though they have the same needs. A parent attending a 20-minute meeting is different from a substitute teacher responsible for 24 students all day. The level of preparation should match the person's exposure, duration, location, and responsibility.

Substitutes Deserve Special Attention

Of all these groups, substitute teachers may present the clearest example of the problem. They aren't simply visitors. For the day, they may assume many of the responsibilities normally held by the classroom teacher: taking attendance, supervising students, moving students between locations, and supervising lunch, recess, arrival, dismissal, or other activities outside the classroom. Yet substitutes can enter unfamiliar schools with relatively little time to orient themselves to the building.

Research reinforces the broader concern. A systematic review of substitute-teacher research described substitutes as an essential and ubiquitous part of the school workforce while also finding limited research concerning their working conditions, experiences, and support. Some states have recognized this issue explicitly. Texas, for example, requires school district multi-hazard emergency operations plans to provide for emergency-response training for district employees, including substitute teachers, as well as access to a telephone or other electronic communication device for immediate contact with emergency services. A substitute should not have to discover the school's emergency procedures when the emergency announcement begins.

What Does a Substitute Actually Need to Know?

Schools sometimes respond by putting an emergency procedures sheet in the substitute folder. That's a good start. But think about the situation from the substitute's perspective. They may need to know what emergency terminology the school uses, how notifications will be received, where classroom emergency information is located, whether the classroom door locks and how, the primary evacuation route, how students are accounted for, how to report a missing or injured student, and who to contact when unsure.

That sounds like a lot. But it can be distilled into a very short orientation if the school intentionally designs one, part of the broader approach to testing systems honestly described in You Don't Need More Drills, You Need Better Drills. The goal isn't to make the substitute an emergency-management expert. The goal is to make sure the substitute can recognize the action, protect the students in their care, communicate, account for people, and follow the school's emergency system.

The Five-Minute Safety Orientation

One practical solution is to develop a five-minute safety orientation for substitutes and other individuals who will assume responsibility for students. It could happen during check-in and be reinforced by a one-page quick-reference card in every classroom, covering five things: how will you know something is happening, what are you expected to do, where is the information you need, how do you communicate, and who can help you.

Five minutes will not replicate annual staff training. It doesn't need to. It closes the gap between knowing nothing and having enough information to function within the school's emergency system.

Visitors Are Different

A parent attending an IEP meeting probably doesn't need the same emergency orientation as a substitute teacher. But that doesn't mean visitors should be ignored. The federal Guide for Developing High-Quality School Emergency Operations Plans emphasizes planning for accounting for all persons, communications, evacuation, shelter-in-place, lockdown, reunification, and other critical emergency functions. Notice the important phrase: all persons.

Emergency accountability cannot stop with students and employees. If a fire alarm activates at 10:17 a.m., do we know there were three contractors in the mechanical area, that a parent was meeting with the counselor, or that six volunteers were working in the library? And does anyone know whether those people evacuated? This is where the visitor-management process becomes part of the emergency-management process.

Schools often think of visitor management primarily as a prevention and access-control strategy. Who entered? Were they screened? Where are they supposed to be? Those are important questions. But during an emergency, the same system should help answer another: who was inside the building when the incident occurred?

That means schools should determine how visitor information will be accessed during an evacuation, lockdown, reunification, or other emergency. Can someone access the visitor list if the front office has been evacuated? How will responders know contractors may be working in an isolated part of the facility? A visitor system that works beautifully during normal operations but becomes inaccessible during an emergency has limited value for accountability.

Contractors Create a Different Problem: Location

Contractors can be particularly challenging because they may work in places most staff and students rarely occupy: mechanical rooms, roofs, utility areas, construction zones, electrical rooms, kitchens, athletic facilities, portable buildings, behind stages, above ceilings, and exterior areas. They may also be performing work that affects building systems, electricity, alarms, HVAC, doors, communications, fire suppression, or utilities.

That creates two planning considerations. First, do they know what to do if the school initiates an emergency action? Second, does the school know where they are? Imagine an evacuation caused by a suspected gas leak. The student accountability process works perfectly. But two contractors are working in a mechanical room on the opposite side of the campus. Who knows they are there? That information could matter enormously to incident command and responding firefighters.

Volunteers create another category. Some visit once. Others are on campus every week. Some work directly with students. Some supervise groups. The more regularly someone is on campus, and the greater their responsibility for students, the stronger the case for providing additional emergency preparation. A useful principle is: emergency preparation should increase as responsibility, exposure, and independence increase.

A visitor escorted by an employee throughout a 30-minute meeting may need little more than basic emergency instructions. A volunteer independently supervising students every Tuesday may need considerably more. That doesn't require treating volunteers exactly like employees. It requires matching preparation to the role.

There is another important dimension to this conversation. Not every visitor, substitute, volunteer, or contractor will be able to receive information or take protective actions in the same way. The Texas School Safety Center's preparedness standards, for example, recommend integrating the needs of students, staff, and visitors with disabilities and others with access and functional needs throughout emergency planning, training, and drilling.

This shouldn't be treated as a separate planning problem. It should be part of the same question: who might be on our campus, and what might they need from us during an emergency?

Create Levels of Emergency Orientation

Rather than developing one process for everyone, schools can create simple levels. Level 1, short-term visitors such as parents attending meetings or delivery personnel, need basic information at check-in: how emergency instructions will be communicated, to follow staff directions, and where to go if evacuation occurs.

Level 2, regular visitors, volunteers, and contractors, should add basic protective-action terminology, notification methods, evacuation expectations, accountability and check-out procedures, and an emergency contact method. Level 3, individuals responsible for students such as substitutes and volunteers who independently supervise students, need a more complete orientation covering protective actions, student accountability, communications, classroom emergency resources, evacuation and relocation, and how to request assistance. The purpose isn't bureaucracy. It is to provide the right information to the right person based on their role.

Put Emergency Information Where People Actually Need It

A district can develop an excellent substitute handbook that no substitute remembers reading six months later. Preparedness needs to exist at the point of use. Consider placing a simple emergency quick-reference card in every instructional space, answering immediate questions: what do our emergency actions mean, where do I evacuate, how do I account for students, how do I communicate, where are emergency materials, and who do I contact for help?

The same principle can apply to visitor badges, contractor check-in materials, volunteer handbooks, digital visitor systems, and QR-based resources. Keep the information concise. During an emergency, people need actionable information, not another manual, a theme we return to in our active shooter protocol guide.

Include Them in Drills, When They Are There

There is also a simple opportunity schools sometimes miss. If substitutes, contractors, volunteers, or visitors happen to be on campus when a drill occurs, don't automatically treat their presence as an inconvenience. It may be one of the best opportunities to test the system. Does the substitute understand the announcement? Does the volunteer know whether to stay with students? Does the contractor hear the notification?

Federal guidance emphasizes training and exercises as part of implementing and continually refining school EOPs, and CDC preparedness guidance likewise recommends exercises to familiarize staff and students with emergency plans. The exercise can reveal whether the system works for people who don't live inside it every day. That is valuable information.

Test Your Plan With the 'Tuesday at 10:00' Question

Here is a simple exercise for a school safety team. Don't use the first day of school. Don't use a staff development day. Instead ask: who might realistically be inside this building at 10:00 a.m. on a random Tuesday in February? Write down everyone: students, teachers, administrators, substitutes, custodians, food-service employees, parents, volunteers, contractors, vendors, therapists, delivery personnel, student teachers, coaches, community partners, and visitors attending meetings.

Now walk through one emergency, maybe a fire, a gas leak, a severe weather warning, or a dangerous person. For each group, ask how will they receive the emergency message, will they understand what it means, what do we expect them to do, who is responsible for them, how will we account for them, and what happens if they are alone when the emergency begins? That discussion may expose gaps that another review of the written EOP never would, a process similar to the one described in our campus walkthrough guide.

This issue also highlights how important front-office personnel are to school safety. They often control the transition between outside the organization and inside the emergency system. They check in substitutes, process visitors, issue badges, interact with vendors, and know when contractors arrive.

That means front-office emergency procedures should include more than access control. Staff should understand what information must be provided when someone arrives, what records need to remain accessible during an emergency, and how to tell incident command or responders about contractors or visitors who may still be inside. This is a good example of why school safety is a system, not a collection of isolated procedures.

Preparedness Has to Include Whoever Happens to Be There

The strongest emergency plans aren't built only for the people who attend annual training. They are built for the people who will actually be present when something happens. Sometimes that will be the principal who has led dozens of drills. Sometimes it will be a first-year teacher. And sometimes it will be a substitute who walked into the building 45 minutes earlier.

The practical implication is simple: your emergency system has to work for people who didn't help build it. That means preparing substitutes before they take responsibility for students, giving visitors enough information to respond appropriately, knowing where contractors are working, preparing regular volunteers for the responsibilities they assume, and accounting for people with access and functional needs, a theme we also explore in Preparing Without Frightening.

A Practical Next Step

Pick one school this week and follow four people through the check-in process: a substitute, a parent visitor, a contractor, and a volunteer. Don't change anything yet. Just observe what each person receives before entering the building. Then ask one question: if an emergency started five minutes from now, would this person know enough to take the right action? If the answer is uncertain, you have found something worth improving.

Put It into Practice

Schools don't need to turn every visitor into an emergency-management expert. But everyone inside the building should have a reasonable chance of knowing what is happening, what they should do, and where they should get help. School Safety Solutions can help districts build these layered orientation processes as part of our broader school safety services. If you'd like help designing one for your district, reach out to start the conversation.

School Safety Solutions helps K-12 leaders strengthen prevention, protection, and preparedness through practical assessment, training, tabletop exercises, Standard Response Protocol implementation, behavioral threat assessment support, and reunification planning. If your district wants a calm, working review of its active shooter protocol and broader emergency readiness, visit School Safety Solutions or call 512-387-6729 to talk through next steps.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page